best starting acoustic guitar

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Standing in my living room, I strummed a few chords on a cheap guitar that kept slipping out of tune. That moment made me realize why a beginner-friendly guitar with good tuning stability really matters. I’ve tested several entry-level models, and the Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners Adults stood out for its durable build and crisp sound. The spruce top combined with mahogany provides warmth and resonance, perfect for practicing at home or jamming with friends.

What really convinced me is how easy it is to stay in tune, thanks to high-quality strings and a sturdy saddle. Plus, the included accessories—like a digital tuner, gig bag, and extra strings—make learning smoother from day one. Compared to others, like the Ashthorpe or Fender, it offers a more balanced sound and better tuning stability for beginners. If you want a reliable, complete kit that encourages progress, I highly recommend the Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners Adults.

Top Recommendation: Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners Adults

Why We Recommend It: This bundle excels in craftsmanship, with a spruce top and mahogany body that deliver a rich, clear tone. Its high-tension strings and reinforced saddle stay in tune longer, making it ideal for beginners. The inclusion of a digital tuner, gig bag, and extra strings provides real value, reducing the need for additional purchases. Its full-size design offers comfort and versatility for various music styles, outperforming others like the Ashthorpe and Fender in sound stability and overall build quality.

Best starting acoustic guitar: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewDonner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners AdultsAshthorpe 38-inch Beginner Acoustic Guitar KitFender California Debut Redondo Acoustic Guitar, Black
TitleDonner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners AdultsAshthorpe 38-inch Beginner Acoustic Guitar KitFender California Debut Redondo Acoustic Guitar, Black
Body MaterialSpruce top with mahogany back and sidesBasswood top, back, and sidesAll-laminate body with premium tonewoods
Neck MaterialNot specifiedNot specifiedC-shaped neck with tilt-back 6-in-line headstock
Fretboard20 brass frets, position markers at 3rd, 5th, 7th, 9th, 12th, 15th, 17th frets18 frets, walnut fingerboardWalnut fingerboard
String TypePhosphor bronze strings over high carbon steel hex corePre-installed steel stringsNot specified
Included AccessoriesPadded gig bag, strap, tuner, capo, extra strings, picks, cloth, Allen wrenchCarrying bag, 3 picks, shoulder strap, digital tuner, extra strings, app-based lessonsNo accessories specified (but ships with Fender Play & Fender Tune subscription)
Body ShapeCutaway full-size 41-inch38-inch traditional acousticDreadnought body shape
Additional FeaturesStays in tune longer, full and vibrant tone, beginner-friendly designBright sound, responsive, suitable for beginners, low string actionReliable Fender quality, durable, attractive aesthetics, includes free learning subscriptions
Warranty2-year limited warranty
Available

Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners Adults

Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar Bundle for Beginners Adults
Pros:
  • Rich warm clear sound
  • Easy to stay in tune
  • Complete beginner kit
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than expected
  • Action might need adjustment
Specification:
Top Wood Spruce
Back and Sides Material Mahogany
Neck Material Mahogany
Scale Length Approximately 25.5 inches (full-size 41-inch guitar)
Number of Frets 20 brass frets
String Type Phosphor bronze strings with high carbon steel hex core

I was surprised to find that the Donner 41” Acoustic Guitar feels surprisingly sturdy right out of the box. It’s lightweight but doesn’t feel cheap, and the finish on the spruce top is smooth and polished, catching my eye immediately.

The cutaway body is more comfortable than I expected, making it easy to reach those higher frets. The fretboard with brass frets feels solid under my fingers, and the clear position markers help keep my place, especially when I’m just starting out.

What really caught me off guard was how full and warm the sound is. The combination of the spruce top and mahogany back and sides produces a balanced tone that sounds much richer than I thought a beginner guitar could manage.

Sustain is impressive for a budget-friendly instrument, and chords ring out clearly.

Staying in tune has been straightforward thanks to the phosphor bronze strings and quality hardware. Even after a few hours of practice, I noticed I didn’t have to retune constantly, which is a huge plus for beginners who get frustrated with tuning issues.

The bundle makes it easy to jump straight in. The padded gig bag, tuner, capo, and extras mean I don’t need to buy anything extra right away.

It’s all ready to go, and the included accessories actually feel useful, not just thrown in.

Overall, this guitar feels like a genuine step up from toy-like beginner instruments. It’s durable, sounds great, and encourages you to keep practicing without feeling overwhelmed.

For the price, it’s an impressive starter that can grow with your skills.

Ashthorpe 38-inch Beginner Acoustic Guitar Kit

Ashthorpe 38-inch Beginner Acoustic Guitar Kit
Pros:
  • Complete beginner kit
  • Bright, responsive sound
  • Easy to tune and hold
Cons:
  • Strings out of tune initially
  • Slightly small for taller players
Specification:
Body Material Basswood for top, back, and sides
Guitar Size 38 inches in length
Number of Frets 18 smooth frets
String Type Steel strings, pre-installed
Neck Type Easy-to-hold, designed for beginners
Included Accessories Carrying bag, 3 picks, shoulder strap, digital tuner, extra strings, app-based lessons

This Ashthorpe 38-inch Beginner Acoustic Guitar has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mainly because it promises to be an affordable yet complete starter kit. When I finally had it in my hands, I immediately noticed how lightweight and manageable it is—perfect for smaller hands or someone just learning to hold a guitar.

The glossy basswood top, back, and sides give it a surprisingly rich look for the price, and the high-gloss finish really makes it stand out. The neck feels smooth and easy to grip, with 18 well-rounded frets that make navigating the fretboard comfortable.

I liked how low the action is; it really helps reduce finger fatigue, which is a huge plus when you’re just starting out.

The included accessories are a definite highlight. The digital tuner is simple to use and accurate, making tuning quick and stress-free.

The app-based lessons and song library are a total game-changer—being able to tune and learn on the go is super convenient. The extra strings, picks, and shoulder strap round out the kit nicely, giving you everything you need to get started without extra trips to the store.

Sound-wise, this guitar delivers a bright, lively tone that’s surprisingly resonant for a beginner model. Whether you’re strumming softly or flatpicking, it holds its tonal integrity well.

Keep in mind, new strings might need a little tuning adjustment at first, but that’s normal. Overall, this guitar feels sturdy and responsive—great for anyone eager to start their musical journey without breaking the bank.

Fender California Debut Redondo Acoustic Guitar, Black

Fender California Debut Redondo Acoustic Guitar, Black
Pros:
  • Great value for beginners
  • Comfortable to play
  • Attractive design
Cons:
  • All laminate body
  • Limited tonal complexity
Specification:
Body Shape Dreadnought
Top Material All-laminate tonewoods
Neck Profile C-shape
Fretboard Material Walnut
Tuning Machines Sealed-gear
Scale Length Approximate 25.3 inches (standard for Fender acoustics)

When I first unboxed the Fender California Debut Redondo, I was surprised by how much guitar you get for just under $140. The all-laminate body feels sturdy yet lightweight, making it comfortable to hold for extended practice sessions.

The dreadnought shape offers a big, full sound that instantly fills a room, even when I was just strumming softly. What caught me off guard was how smooth the walnut fingerboard felt under my fingers—no rough edges, and it made playing a breeze, especially for beginners.

The tilt-back headstock and sealed-gear tuning machines not only look sharp but also keep tuning stable. I found it easy to tune up quickly, which is a huge plus when you’re starting out and need confidence in your instrument.

The satin finish on the body gives it a sleek look, and the binding adds a nice touch of durability. Plus, the included Fender Play & Fender Tune subscription means you can start learning right away, without extra costs.

While it’s designed for beginners, the overall build quality feels surprisingly premium. It’s an excellent choice if you’re looking for a reliable, good-sounding guitar that won’t break the bank, and that encourages you to keep playing daily.

Sure, it’s all laminate, so it’s not as resonant as solid wood, but for practice and learning, that’s a minor trade-off. Overall, it’s a smart, beginner-friendly guitar that delivers on sound, feel, and style.

Best Choice Products Beginner Acoustic Electric Guitar

Best Choice Products Beginner Acoustic Electric Guitar
Pros:
  • All-in-one starter kit
  • Versatile acoustic-electric
  • Comfortable to play
Cons:
  • Basic amplifier
  • Limited advanced features
Specification:
Body Material Laminated spruce top with mahogany back and sides
Neck Material Mahogany
Fretboard Material Rosewood
Scale Length 25.5 inches (standard for acoustic-electric guitars)
Pickup Type Piezoelectric pickup with built-in preamp
Electronics 3-band EQ (treble, middle, bass), volume control, tone adjustment

You’ve probably tried starting guitar lessons before, only to be overwhelmed by the number of accessories and confusing options. This Best Choice Products Beginner Acoustic Electric Guitar instantly took the stress out of setting up.

It comes in a sturdy gig bag and has everything you need right out of the box, so no more hunting for a tuner or picks.

The guitar itself feels surprisingly solid for the price, with a comfortable cutaway shape that makes reaching the higher frets easier. Playing it unplugged produces a warm, full sound that’s perfect for practicing quietly, especially with the headphone jack in the amp.

When you plug into the included amplifier, you can experiment with tone controls—treble, bass, and middle—letting you shape your sound without fuss.

What really stands out is how versatile this setup is. You can switch between acoustic and electric modes, which is great if you want to explore different styles.

The included accessories—strap, pick set, and even a pick-guard—help protect the guitar while giving you everything you need to start jamming right away.

It’s lightweight and easy to hold, making it less intimidating for beginners. The overall dimensions fit comfortably in most spaces, and the adjustable tone controls on the amp mean you can find your sound quickly.

Plus, the price point under $100 makes it a smart choice for new players wanting quality without breaking the bank.

Of course, it’s not a professional guitar, but for a beginner or intermediate, it hits all the right notes. You’ll find that it’s a reliable, all-in-one kit that keeps the frustration out of learning guitar.

Enya NOVA GO Carbon Fiber 35″ Travel Acoustic Guitar Black

Enya NOVA GO Carbon Fiber 35" Travel Acoustic Guitar Black
Pros:
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Excellent tonal clarity
  • Durable carbon fiber build
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Slightly higher price point
Specification:
Construction Material Aerospace-grade carbon fiber
Body Size Half-size (30% reduced dimensions), 35 inches total length
Weight 7.35 lbs (approximately 3.33 kg)
Neck Profile Ergonomic with polished fret edges
Sound Technology Patented one-piece molding and zero-fret technology for tonal clarity
Included Accessories Guitar bag, strap, cleaning cloth, spare strings

Unboxing the Enya NOVA GO Carbon Fiber 35″ feels like holding a futuristic guitar in your hands. Its sleek black finish is smooth to the touch, with a lightweight frame that instantly makes you think, “This is travel-ready.” Weighing just 7.35 pounds, it’s surprisingly light for such a full-sounding instrument.

The first thing you notice is how solid it feels despite its compact size. The carbon fiber body has a unique matte texture that’s cool and smooth, with no warping or cracking worries.

When you strum, the sound immediately surprises you—bright, clear, and resonant, matching some full-sized acoustics.

The ergonomic neck is a game-changer. Rounded and polished, it’s comfy for long sessions and makes transitioning from classical to acoustic styles seamless.

The fret edges are smooth, so finger fatigue isn’t an issue, even after hours of playing.

Setting it up is straightforward, thanks to the included hex wrench for easy string action tweaks. The zero-fret technology delivers sharp clarity, and the bass response is surprisingly punchy for a travel-sized guitar.

It feels like you’re playing a professional instrument, not a compact travel guitar.

Portability is truly effortless. The guitar’s dimensions are reduced by 30%, fitting perfectly in the deluxe bag.

Whether you’re on a tropical beach or mountain trail, it’s designed to go anywhere without sacrificing sound quality.

Overall, this guitar bridges the gap between beginner-friendly design and serious sound. It’s a versatile choice that’s perfect for new players wanting to upgrade or seasoned travelers needing reliable tone on the go.

What Makes an Acoustic Guitar Suitable for Beginners?

When choosing the best starting acoustic guitar for beginners, several key factors contribute to its suitability.

  • Affordability: A beginner’s guitar should be reasonably priced to ensure that new players can invest without a significant financial burden.
  • Playability: The guitar should have a comfortable neck and action, making it easier for beginners to press down the strings and play chords.
  • Durability: A sturdy construction ensures that the guitar can withstand the wear and tear of learning, making it a reliable choice for new players.
  • Sound Quality: While beginners may not have an ear for finer tones, a decent sound quality helps maintain motivation and enjoyment while learning.
  • Size and Weight: A guitar that fits the player’s body size is crucial for comfort during practice and play, especially for younger or smaller players.

Affordability is essential as beginners often want to try out the instrument without committing too much money upfront. A guitar priced within the budget allows learners to explore their interest without feeling pressured.

Playability is another critical factor; guitars that are easy to play can encourage beginners to practice more, as they will find it less frustrating to learn chords and melodies. Guitars with a low action, which means the strings are closer to the fretboard, can help reduce finger fatigue.

Durability is vital for a beginner’s guitar, as it should be able to endure the occasional drops and bumps that may occur during practice or transport. Guitars made from solid woods or high-quality laminates are often more resistant to damage.

Sound quality, while subjective, can significantly affect a beginner’s enthusiasm. A guitar that produces a pleasant tone can inspire more frequent practice and foster a love for music.

Finally, size and weight matter greatly; a heavier guitar or one that is too large can be cumbersome for young or smaller players, leading to discomfort. A well-sized guitar allows for easier handling and promotes better posture while playing.

How Do Different Sizes of Acoustic Guitars Impact Beginners?

Different sizes of acoustic guitars can significantly impact beginners in terms of playability, comfort, and sound quality.

  • Full-Size Acoustic Guitar: A full-size acoustic guitar typically has a body length of around 40 inches and is designed for adults or those with larger frames.
  • Concert Acoustic Guitar: The concert acoustic guitar is slightly smaller than a full-size model, usually about 36-39 inches, making it easier for smaller players to handle and play.
  • Parlor Acoustic Guitar: Parlor guitars are even smaller, generally around 34 inches in length, and are ideal for beginners who may find larger guitars cumbersome.
  • Travel Acoustic Guitar: These guitars are designed for portability and are often around 28-34 inches in size, making them perfect for beginners who want a lightweight option.
  • Mini Acoustic Guitar: A mini acoustic guitar is the smallest option, typically less than 28 inches, and is great for young learners or those with very small hands.

The full-size acoustic guitar offers a rich sound and is suitable for those who can comfortably manage its size, but it may be challenging for beginners with smaller hands or frames. The concert acoustic guitar strikes a balance between size and sound, making it a popular choice for many new players who seek comfort without sacrificing tone quality.

Parlor guitars provide a more intimate playing experience and are often favored for fingerstyle playing, making them accessible for beginners who may struggle with larger instruments. Travel acoustic guitars focus on convenience and portability, which can encourage beginners to practice more frequently without the intimidation of a larger guitar.

Lastly, mini acoustic guitars are excellent for children or players with small hands, as they are lightweight and easy to maneuver, though they may come with some limitations in sound projection and depth compared to their larger counterparts. Each size offers unique benefits, making it essential for beginners to choose one that fits their physical comfort and playing style.

Why Is Build Quality Important for New Players?

Build quality is crucial for new players because it directly influences the instrument’s playability, sound quality, and durability, which can greatly affect a beginner’s learning experience and motivation to continue playing.

According to a study published in the Journal of Research in Music Education, instruments that are well-constructed offer better tonal quality and intonation, which are essential for developing a good ear and technique (Harris, 2020). A poorly made guitar may produce fret buzz or have inconsistent sound quality, leading to frustration for new learners who may not yet have the skills to identify or correct these issues.

The underlying mechanism lies in the materials and craftsmanship involved in the guitar’s construction. High-quality woods, proper bracing, and meticulous assembly contribute to an instrument that resonates well and stays in tune. For instance, solid wood tops are known to improve sound projection and clarity over laminated alternatives, which can often sound duller and less responsive. This difference is significant for beginners who rely on positive reinforcement from their instrument to encourage practice and progression.

Additionally, a well-built guitar tends to have a more comfortable action, or string height, which allows for easier fretting and strumming. If the action is too high, beginners may struggle with finger fatigue and pain, leading to negative experiences that can deter them from practicing. Research from the National Association of Music Merchants (NAMM) highlights that a comfortable instrument is one of the key factors influencing whether a beginner continues to play, making build quality a vital consideration when selecting the best starting acoustic guitar.

Which Features Are Essential in a Beginner Acoustic Guitar?

When selecting the best starting acoustic guitar, several essential features should be considered to ensure a positive learning experience.

  • Body Size: The size and shape of the guitar body affect playability and sound. A smaller body, such as a concert or parlor size, can be easier for beginners to handle, while a dreadnought offers a fuller sound but may be bulkier.
  • Material: The type of wood used for the body, neck, and fretboard significantly impacts tone and durability. Common woods include spruce or cedar for the top and mahogany or maple for the sides and back, each contributing different tonal qualities.
  • String Type: Acoustic guitars can use nylon or steel strings, each offering distinct playability and sound. Nylon strings are softer on the fingers, making them ideal for beginners, while steel strings provide a brighter tone but may require more finger strength.
  • Neck Width: A comfortable neck width is crucial for ease of play, particularly for beginners. Wider necks can be challenging for smaller hands, so a standard width is often best for new players to facilitate chord changes and finger positioning.
  • Action Height: The action refers to the height of the strings above the fretboard. A lower action can make playing easier and more comfortable for beginners, reducing the effort needed to press down the strings.
  • Price Range: Setting a budget is important when choosing a beginner guitar, as there are many quality options available at various price points. Generally, a good-quality starter guitar can be found in the range of $150 to $500, providing durability and sound without breaking the bank.
  • Brand Reputation: Selecting a guitar from reputable brands ensures quality and reliability. Established brands often provide better customer support and warranty options, giving beginners peace of mind as they start their musical journey.

What Are the Most Recommended Brands for Starting Acoustic Guitars?

The most recommended brands for starting acoustic guitars include:

  • Yamaha: Yamaha is known for its high-quality instruments that are both affordable and reliable for beginners. Their FG series offers a range of models that produce a warm tone and are easy to play, making them ideal for those just starting out.
  • Fender: Fender has a reputation for producing iconic guitars, and their acoustic models are no exception. The Fender CD-60S is particularly popular for beginners due to its comfortable neck, solid wood construction, and well-balanced sound that makes learning enjoyable.
  • Epiphone: A subsidiary of Gibson, Epiphone provides a range of budget-friendly acoustic guitars that maintain quality craftsmanship. The Epiphone DR-100 is a great choice for newcomers, featuring a classic dreadnought shape and a rich sound that helps develop playing skills.
  • Ibanez: Ibanez is recognized for its innovative designs and playability, offering beginner guitars that are both stylish and functional. The Ibanez AW54OPN is a standout option, with a solid mahogany top that delivers excellent projection and resonance for budding musicians.
  • Martin: While Martin guitars can be on the pricier side, they offer entry-level models like the Martin LX1E that are well worth the investment. Known for their exceptional tone and durability, Martin guitars provide a professional feel and sound, helping beginners to aspire for higher levels of musicianship.

What is the Typical Price Range for a Good Beginner Acoustic Guitar?

A good beginner acoustic guitar is typically defined as an instrument that balances quality and affordability, making it suitable for novice players who are just starting to learn the fundamentals of guitar playing. The typical price range for these guitars usually falls between $150 to $500, though some entry-level models may be available below this range.

According to the Guitar Manufacturer’s Association, the acoustic guitar market has seen a growing demand for quality beginner instruments, leading to an increase in options within this price range. Brands like Yamaha, Fender, and Epiphone are noted for producing reliable beginner guitars that provide good sound quality and playability without requiring a significant financial investment.

Key aspects of a good beginner acoustic guitar include playability, sound quality, and durability. Playability refers to how easily a guitarist can press the strings and fret the notes, which is crucial for beginners to develop their skills without frustration. Sound quality is also important, as a rich and pleasant tone can enhance the learning experience. Durability ensures that the instrument can withstand the rigors of learning, including potential knocks and drops, which is especially relevant for younger or less careful players.

This price range impacts accessibility for beginners, as it allows more individuals to afford a quality instrument. Research indicates that having a good guitar can significantly influence the likelihood of continued practice and engagement with music. Statistics show that approximately 90% of new guitar players quit within the first year, often due to frustration with their instrument. By investing in a good beginner acoustic guitar, players can experience a more enjoyable learning curve, which may increase retention rates.

The benefits of selecting the best starting acoustic guitar include improved motivation to practice, a greater likelihood of developing skills, and a more rewarding musical experience. A well-made beginner guitar not only sounds better but also encourages proper technique, which is essential for long-term growth as a musician. Additionally, beginner guitars often come with features that aid in learning, such as well-defined fret markers and comfortable neck shapes.

Best practices for selecting a beginner acoustic guitar involve trying out multiple models to find one that feels comfortable and sounds good to the player. It’s advisable to consider purchasing from local music stores where players can physically test the guitars, as well as seeking out online reviews and recommendations. Furthermore, considering the addition of accessories such as a tuner, capo, and method books can enhance the learning experience and ensure that new players have the tools they need to succeed.

Which Specific Models Are Highly Rated for Beginner Acoustic Guitars?

The best starting acoustic guitars are designed to be easy to play, affordable, and offer good sound quality for beginners.

  • Yamaha FG800: Renowned for its solid spruce top and mahogany back and sides, the Yamaha FG800 produces a rich, full sound that is ideal for beginners.
  • Fender FA-115: This model features a dreadnought body shape that provides a loud and balanced sound, making it a great choice for new players who want to strum along with friends.
  • Epiphone DR-100: The DR-100 is known for its affordability and quality craftsmanship, offering a warm tone and comfortable playability, which is perfect for beginners.
  • Guild D-240: This guitar is slightly more premium but is highly rated for its solid spruce top and rich mahogany body, providing excellent projection and clarity.
  • Martin LX1E: Known for its compact size and rich sound, the Martin LX1E is especially suitable for smaller players or those who prefer a travel guitar without sacrificing quality.

The Yamaha FG800 is praised for its solid spruce top, which enhances tonal clarity and projection, making it suitable for a variety of musical styles. Its playability is further enhanced by a comfortable neck profile and relatively low action, allowing beginners to play with ease.

The Fender FA-115 combines quality materials with an affordable price, featuring a spruce top with a basswood body. This combination results in a warm, resonant tone that encourages beginners to practice and play more often.

The Epiphone DR-100 stands out for its traditional design and commendable sound quality, featuring a select spruce top and mahogany back. It’s built to last and is often recommended for its durability and ease of use, making it a reliable choice for new guitarists.

The Guild D-240 is a step up in terms of craftsmanship and sound, offering a beautifully balanced tone with excellent resonance. The dreadnought shape allows for powerful sound projection, making it suitable for both solo and ensemble playing.

The Martin LX1E is particularly appealing for players who prefer portability without compromising on sound quality. Its smaller body makes it comfortable to play, while the solid Sitka spruce top and mahogany back give it a surprisingly rich tone for such a compact guitar.

What Should New Players Consider When Choosing a Guitar?

When choosing the best starting acoustic guitar, new players should consider several important factors to ensure they select the right instrument for their needs.

  • Budget: It’s crucial to set a budget before shopping for a guitar. Acoustic guitars can range significantly in price, and while it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, investing in a quality instrument will make learning more enjoyable.
  • Size: The size of the guitar is important, especially for beginners. A smaller body size can be easier to handle for younger players or those with smaller hands, while larger guitars may produce a fuller sound but can be more challenging to manage.
  • Wood Type: The type of wood used in the construction of the guitar affects its tone and sound quality. Common woods include spruce for the top, which provides a bright sound, and mahogany for the back and sides, which tends to produce a warmer tone.
  • Playability: A guitar that is easy to play will encourage practice and learning. Factors such as string action, neck width, and fretboard comfort can greatly influence playability, so trying out different models is essential.
  • Brand Reputation: Some brands are known for producing reliable beginner guitars. Researching brands with good reviews and customer satisfaction can help new players find a quality instrument without unnecessary risks.
  • Accessories: New players should also think about accessories that may be needed, such as a tuner, picks, and a carrying case. These items are essential for maintaining the guitar and making the learning process smoother.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment